There’s Nothing Democratic About These Socialists

The Democratic Socialists of America (DSA) has adopted increasingly radical positions, including support for Palestinian resistance and opposition to Western military aid, prompting criticism that it no longer aligns with democratic values. This shift is significant because it challenges the group’s original goal of building a democratic socialist movement within the framework of American democracy.

Founded in 1982 by Michael Harrington, the DSA originally aimed to promote socialism compatible with democratic norms, explicitly distancing itself from communist authoritarianism. Over time, especially following the rise of Bernie Sanders and the influx of younger, more radical members, the organization experienced internal factions defending Harrington’s principles and warning against authoritarian tendencies.

However, recent actions, particularly after the October 7, 2023, Hamas attacks, have marked a stark departure. The DSA’s New York City chapter and other local groups publicly affirmed the Palestinian ‘right to resist’ and supported protests celebrating the attacks. These positions have been criticized for blurring the lines between legitimate resistance and terrorism, leading to resignations among longtime members who accuse the organization of abandoning democratic principles.

Additionally, the DSA’s stance on Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, blaming Western expansionism rather than Russian aggression, and its opposition to military aid for Ukraine, reflect a broader tilt toward anti-Western, and in some cases authoritarian, alliances. The group’s 2025 convention voted to remove language that allowed expulsion of members linked to communist groups, further signaling a shift away from its original anti-authoritarian stance.

Implications of the DSA’s Ideological Shift

The DSA’s move away from its founding democratic principles could reshape left-wing politics in the U.S., potentially undermining democratic norms within progressive circles. Its support for controversial positions on the Israel-Palestine conflict and foreign policy may polarize the movement and alienate moderate supporters. This evolution raises questions about the future of democratic socialism in America and whether the organization can reconcile its radical positions with its original mission of promoting democratic values.

Historical Roots and Recent Radicalization of the DSA

The DSA was established in 1982 by Michael Harrington to promote socialism rooted in democratic principles, explicitly opposing communist authoritarianism. For decades, it supported policies like social security, higher minimum wages, and opposition to authoritarian regimes. However, the rise of Bernie Sanders and the influx of new members in the past decade brought a more radical faction into prominence.

Internal conflicts emerged between traditionalists committed to Harrington’s vision and newer members advocating for more militant, anti-Western, and anti-Israel positions. The organization’s stance on international issues, including Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and the recent Hamas attacks, reflects this ideological shift. The 2025 convention’s decision to remove language protecting democratic norms signals a further move away from Harrington’s original vision.

“Principles of liberty and equality are indispensable to the self-government of a free people.”

— Michael Harrington

Unclear Future of DSA’s Democratic Commitments

It remains uncertain whether the DSA will reverse its recent positions and realign with its original democratic principles or continue on its current radical trajectory. The organization’s internal debates and external criticisms suggest ongoing divisions, but the outcome is not yet clear.

Next Steps for the DSA and Left-Wing Politics

The DSA is expected to hold further internal debates and possibly new conventions to define its ideological stance. Its influence on Democratic Party politics and broader left-wing movements will depend on whether it can reconcile its radical positions with democratic norms. Observers will watch for signs of internal reform or further radicalization.

Key Questions

Has the DSA officially abandoned democratic socialism?

The DSA’s recent positions, especially after October 7, 2023, suggest a move away from its original democratic socialist principles, but it has not issued a formal statement declaring an abandonment.

What caused the recent shift in the DSA’s stance?

The organization’s recent support for Palestinian resistance and opposition to Western military aid, along with internal factional conflicts, have contributed to its ideological shift.

How have longtime members reacted?

Many veteran members have resigned, criticizing the organization for abandoning its democratic principles and aligning with authoritarian causes.

Will the DSA change its positions in the future?

It is unclear; future developments depend on internal debates, leadership decisions, and external pressures, with ongoing divisions likely to influence its trajectory.

What impact could this have on American politics?

The shift could polarize left-wing politics, weaken the influence of democratic norms within progressive circles, and alter the future direction of socialist movements in the U.S.

Source: The Atlantic